fbpx
20621 Fairmount Blvd, Shaker Heights, OH 44118

Cafe

PICNIC HILL MARKET CAFÉ
Dining options
1

Picnic Hill Market Café will offer food for the Everyday Gourmet. A chef with over 30 years experience has created the recipes for our Take Out Gourmet prepared food case and our Bar Menu.

At the Take Out Gourmet case you will discover restaurant caliber Take Out Gourmet with imagination and good taste. There will be fresh salads, homemade soups, and entrees to eat in Picnic Hill’s Cafe or to take out to dine at home.

Our chef chooses the freshest natural ingredients when preparing daily choices with considerations to vegans and those who wish a gluten free diet.

Our lunch menu is available Tuesday – Saturday 11am – 3pm. The dinner menu is available Tuesday – Saturday 3pm – 7pm

For prepared food options see below, for real-time availability of what’s in the case, call us.

Brunch is served Saturday & Sunday 10 am – 3 pm

Picnic Hill Market Café
prepared foods MENU
Prepared fresh daily, limited quantities available. For real-time availability please call us.
1

EGG SALAD
For those familiar, this recipe was inspired by the Russian Tea Room in New York City. All of the familiar flavors are still there, up front and center, for you to enjoy served on a bed of organic spring greens with your favorite crackers as an easy and light appetizer or to slather on a slice of freshly baked pumpernickel or rye bread for a sandwich that’s impossible not to love.

TUNA SALAD
Even Charlie loves our rendition of this all-American classic — the perfect combo of creamy and crunchy and always the perfect choice for an easy and quick lunch! Made with the wild-caught tuna, organic celery, red bell pepper, onion and capers, all lightly tossed and combined with our pantry mayonnaise, its recipe ready for you to wrap and roll or to make a sandwich your way!

TARRAGON CHICKEN SALAD
This soon to be Picnic Hill classic is made with lightly poached breast of all natural chicken, celery and onion. The almonds add a little crunch and texture, and the tarragon and vermouth infused sour cream mayonnaise dressing add a delicious French twist. This recipe was inspired by the chicken salad featured at the iconic West Point Market, formerly in Akron, Ohio.

CAROL’S PASTA SALAD
The salad, has wholesome and colorful ingredients that provide real flavor and is just delicious! The starring cast of colorful, health-supporting vegetables includes broccoli florets, beans, sweet red bell pepper, artichoke hearts, jumbo ripe California black olives, and Picnic Hill’s oven-roasted tomatoes tossed together with bowtie pasta and dressed with classic Italian vinaigrette.

MORE PREPARED FOODS COMING SOON!

CREAMY MASHED POTATOES
All eyes are on our creamy mashed Yukon Gold potatoes. Simply made with butter, cream, salt and pepper. Serve with our signature Shawn’s Granny’s Meatloaf or our crispy Southern Fried Chicken.

SPRING ROASTED VEGETABLES
A flavorful combination of healthy spring roasted vegetables: zucchini, squash, broccoli, bell peppers, red onion and market fresh veggies

GRILLED GREEN BEANS
Fresh, crispy, juicy grilled green beans. Perfect companion to any dish!

MAC & CHEESE
Classic creamy delicious homemade mac and cheese.

CHICKEN POT PIE
If you need to get dinner on the table in a hurry, Picnic Hill’s chicken pot pie is the place to begin! It’s as cozy and comforting as it gets and it’s our best take, with a twist, on the American Classic with a buttery flaky crust and a savory creamy filling with tender all natural chicken, leeks, mushrooms, carrots and peas with fresh tarragon and a splash of sherry.

VEGETABLE LASAGNA
A healthier take on our classic lasagna, instead of meat we have subbed in a mix of mushrooms, zucchini, and spinach. Layered together with ricotta cheese mix and our homemade marinara sauce.

LASAGNA
Our tasteful take on the classic Italian-American dish that brings together all of the things we love in a good pasta dish: noodles, cheese, and fresh herbs with a delicious Bolognese sauce. It’s just like Nonna made and ready when you are to bake and serve with our instructions.

PEACH BALSAMIC CHICKEN

Tender roasted chicken thighs in a peach balsamic glaze. Paired with a spring farro salad & parmesan pea potato cakes.

MEATLOAF DINNER
Granny’s traditional Italian meatloaf with tomato jam and mashed potatoes

LASAGNA 
Featuring Classic Meat Lasagna and Veggie Lasagna

MANGO JERK CHICKEN

Tender grilled chicken thighs rubbed in a sweet and spicy jerk marinade topped with a Caribbean mango salsa. Paired with grilled green beans and parmesan pea potato cakes.

menus